Cyber Defamation: Step-by-Step Procedure
By Advocate Panchanand Shaw, Bar Council of West Bengal · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Cyber Law
A defamatory post is up, and the cyber cell says it cannot register an FIR. That answer is correct in law, and it says nothing about where to go next. This is the sequence a cyber defamation complaint follows, from the notice to the publisher to the platform, the police, and the Magistrate who can summon.
What has to be shown, and what the exceptions allow
A cyber defamation complaint turns on four questions, asked in this order. Was an imputation made about you. Was it published, meaning did somebody other than you and the maker see or read it. Does it lower your reputation in the eyes of an ordinary reader. And does one of the recognised exceptions cover it.
The offence now sits in s. 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, which replaced ss. 499 and 500 of the Indian Penal Code. The Code is repealed, so a complaint drafted today cites the Sanhita, however familiar the older numbers still sound at a police counter.
The exceptions carry as much weight as the offence itself. Truth published for the public good is a defence. So is a fair comment on the conduct of a public servant in the discharge of public functions, and a good-faith report of a court or legislative proceeding. A complaint drafted without regard to them meets the objection at the first hearing, and answering it costs the complainant the initiative.
Why this complaint does not begin at the police station
Defamation under s. 356 is a non-cognizable and bailable offence. That single fact fixes the shape of the whole route. The police cannot register a First Information Report on their own, and cannot investigate without an order of a Magistrate.
A person who carries a printout of a defamatory post to a cyber cell will therefore usually be told that no FIR can be registered. The answer is correct in law and useless in practice, because it does not name the alternative. There are two. A petition to the Magistrate, or a police complaint forwarded to the Magistrate for permission to investigate.
A third door is used more often than either. It opens where the post also carries something else: obscene material under s. 67 of the Information Technology Act 2000, a threat under s. 351 of the Sanhita, or the misuse of another person's identity under s. 66C of the same Act. Those offences are cognizable. An FIR can be registered for them, and the defamation travels with them. Where the statement is borderline, it helps to test it against what amounts to online defamation before choosing the door.
The stages, in order
Six stages, in this order. Each leaves a document behind, and each later stage reads the document the earlier one created. That is the reason for keeping to the order even where a stage looks skippable.
- A notice to the publisher, asking for a retraction and setting out the words complained of.
- A complaint to the platform's grievance officer, which fixes the date the intermediary was told.
- A complaint to the cyber cell or the police station, with a parallel entry on the national portal for cyber crime complaints.
- An application to the Magistrate, either for permission to investigate a non-cognizable offence or as a private complaint.
- An application for interim relief, if the post is still up and still being read.
- Trial, if the matter is contested, and an appeal if either side is aggrieved by the outcome.
The forum changes what can be asked for at each stage. The table below sets that out, because the commonest mistake in these matters is asking the right forum for the wrong thing.
| Forum | What it can order | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|
| Platform grievance officer | Remove the content or suspend the account under the platform's own policy | Decide whether the statement is defamatory, or award compensation |
| Cyber cell | Register an FIR for a cognizable offence, seize devices, obtain subscriber data from the platform | Investigate a non-cognizable offence without a Magistrate's order |
| Magistrate | Take cognizance, summon the accused, order removal, try and punish | Award damages for injured reputation as a civil claim |
| Civil court | Damages and an injunction against further publication | Punish the publisher, or move as quickly as a criminal complaint |
| High Court | Quash a proceeding that abuses process, protect against arrest | Act as a first forum for a defamation complaint |
Stage one: the notice to the publisher
Send a notice to the person who wrote the post, and to the editor or the registered office where the publisher is a company, a news portal or a channel. A notice is not a statutory requirement for defamation, and its absence does not defeat the complaint. It earns its place for three other reasons.
It fixes the date on which the publisher was told the words were false, which is the cleanest answer to a later claim of innocent publication. It gives an honest publisher the chance to retract, and a retraction reduces the harm. And it produces a dated refusal, which is useful material when the same publisher repeats the statement.
Draft the notice around the words themselves. Quote the post, give the address of the page, name the date it was read, and ask for a specific correction. A notice that complains of a campaign without quoting a sentence invites a reply that says nothing defamatory was written. Keep the postal receipt and the acknowledgement, and keep the email header if the notice went by email.
Stage two: the platform's grievance officer
Every intermediary that enjoys the safe harbour of s. 79 of the Information Technology Act 2000 must observe due diligence under the Intermediary Guidelines Rules 2021. Part of that duty is a grievance officer, a published contact, and a mechanism that acknowledges a complaint within twenty-four hours and disposes of it within fifteen days.
The same Rules require an intermediary to remove content within thirty-six hours of receiving a court order or a notification from a competent authority. Read the two obligations together and the limit of this stage becomes clear. The platform will move quickly on an order. It will move slowly, and often not at all, on a complaint that a post is defamatory, because whether a statement is defamatory is a question a grievance officer is not equipped to decide.
File the complaint anyway. The ticket number and the reply are documents. A refusal is as useful as a removal, because it shows the court that the platform was put on notice and did nothing, which is the foundation of a later argument that the safe harbour was forfeited. The order that does move a platform is described in the note on getting a takedown of defamatory content.
Stage three: the police complaint, and the Magistrate's permission
File at the cyber cell, and enter the same facts on the national cyber crime reporting portal so that a number exists independently of the desk officer. Ask for two things in writing: a receipt of the complaint, and a copy of the entry in the station diary.
Where the post carries only defamation, expect the complaint to be treated as non-cognizable. The useful step then is an application to the Magistrate asking that the police be permitted to investigate. The application sets out the post, the publication, the refusal and the provision. Once permission is granted, the investigation proceeds as any other, and the police can seek subscriber details, IP logs and account records from the platform.
Where the post also carries obscene material, a threat or identity misuse, press for an FIR under those provisions at the first visit. The defamation is added by a separate section in the same FIR. This is not a technicality. It decides whether the investigation starts in a week or waits for a court date.
Stage four: the private complaint before the Magistrate
The alternative, and often the faster one, is a complaint filed directly before the Magistrate having jurisdiction over the place where the publication was read. The complainant is examined on oath, and the Magistrate decides whether there is sufficient ground to proceed.
The complaint should name the accused where the identity is known and describe the account where it is not. An unnamed publisher is not a fatal defect at this stage. What the Magistrate needs is enough material to see that an imputation was made and published, and a request that the platform be directed to disclose the subscriber details behind the account.
Limitation is the trap here. A defamation complaint filed long after the post went up will meet an objection that cognizance is barred by delay, and that objection is decided before the merits are touched. Fix the date of first publication and the date you came to know of it, and be ready to explain the gap between them.
Where the sequence stalls
It stalls in four places, and knowing them in advance changes how the complaint is drafted.
- The platform decides the post does not breach its policy. Defamation is a civil wrong as well as an offence, and platforms are cautious about policing opinion. The answer is an order, not a second complaint.
- The police record it as non-cognizable and close the file. The answer is the application to the Magistrate, filed with the refusal attached.
- The account is anonymous. The answer is a direction to the platform for subscriber information, which the police can obtain and a private complainant can ask the court to obtain.
- The accused is outside India, or the platform has no Indian office. The answer is a takedown order against the platform's Indian grievance machinery, which is the part a court in Kolkata can actually reach.
Each of these is a point about forum and power rather than about the strength of the case. A complaint that anticipates them in its prayer avoids a second round of filings, and the papers that support those prayers are listed in the note on cyber defamation documents required.
What to do next
Bring the post, the notice, the platform ticket, the police receipt and the dates to a first consultation, and ask one question: which forum in this sequence can give the relief you want, and in what order. The chambers of Advocate Panchanand Shaw handle cyber defamation complaints before the Calcutta High Court and the district courts in West Bengal, and the practice page on cyber defamation work in Kolkata explains what the engagement covers. Write through the chambers contact page with the address of the post and the date it was published.
Need help with a cyber crime matter?
Tell me what happened and I will tell you what to file, where, and by when. First conversation is free.
Call +91-9007000603 WhatsAppFrequently asked questions
Can I file a cyber defamation FIR directly at a police station?
Not for defamation alone. Defamation under s. 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 is non-cognizable, so the police need a Magistrate's order before investigating. An FIR is possible only where the same post also makes out a cognizable offence, such as obscene publication under s. 67 of the Information Technology Act 2000.
Does the platform have to remove a defamatory post?
The Intermediary Guidelines Rules 2021 require removal within thirty-six hours of a court order or a government notification, and acknowledge a complaint within twenty-four hours. Platforms rarely act on a bare claim of defamation, because that is a contested legal question, so the removal usually follows a court order rather than a grievance ticket.
Where do I file a private defamation complaint?
Before the Magistrate having jurisdiction over the place where the defamatory publication was read. The complainant is examined on oath and the Magistrate decides whether there is ground to proceed. Filing within the limitation period matters, and a delay is argued before the merits of the complaint are reached.
What if the person who posted it is unknown?
A complaint can describe the account instead of naming a person, and ask the court to direct the platform to disclose the subscriber details behind it. The police can obtain the same information during an investigation. Anonymity delays the matter but does not end the route.
Information for general guidance only and not legal advice. Provisions cited follow the Information Technology Act 2000, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.
Related articles
Cyber crime lawyer in your city · Bank account freeze help · Contact