Cyber Defamation Complaint: Documents Required
By Advocate Panchanand Shaw, Bar Council of West Bengal · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Cyber Law
A defamation complaint is decided on paper before it is decided on argument. Four of those papers only you can create, and three cannot be obtained without an order. This is the full list, what each document proves, who issues it, and what to put on the file when the document you need does not exist anymore.
The papers a complaint sinks or swims on
Most cyber defamation complaints that fail early do not fail on the law. They fail because the file cannot show two things: that the words were published to a third person, and that the thing produced in court is a true copy of what was on the screen. Every document below exists to prove one of those two propositions, or to connect the accused to the account.
Sort the file that way before you sort it by date. A thick bundle that proves everything except publication is weaker than a thin one that proves publication twice.
The documents at a glance
Six documents carry the complaint. The rest support them.
| Document | Who issues it | What it proves |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and address proof of the complainant | The complainant, from a government-issued document | That the person complaining is the person defamed |
| Capture of the post, with the page address visible | The complainant, from the device used to read it | That the words existed, in that form, at that address |
| Certificate under s. 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023 | The person in charge of the device that made the capture | That the electronic record is what it purports to be |
| Affidavit of the complainant | The complainant, sworn before an officer empowered to administer the oath | The account of reading it, and the date of knowledge |
| Grievance ticket and the platform's reply | The intermediary's grievance officer | That the intermediary was told, and what it did |
| Complaint receipt or portal acknowledgement | The police station, cyber cell or the national portal | That the criminal complaint was made, and when |
The capture, and the four things that must be on its face
A photograph of a screen taken with another phone is the weakest form of proof and the commonest. It shows words. It does not show where the words were, or when. Four elements must be visible in the same frame or the same file: the address of the page, the handle of the account behind it, the date and time as the page displays them, and the device's own clock.
Take a full-page capture rather than a crop, then a second capture of the comments and shares. A post that has been read by nobody is not published in the sense the offence requires, and the comment thread is often the only proof that anyone saw it.
Keep the file as it came off the device. A capture re-saved through a messaging app loses its metadata and its original timestamp, and the loss is not something you can explain away later.
The certificate that turns a capture into evidence
An electronic record is proved under s. 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023, and sub-section (4) requires a certificate in the form set out in the Schedule to that Act. The certificate identifies the electronic record, describes the manner of its production, gives the hash value of the record where the form asks for it, and is signed by the person in charge of the computer or device on which the record was produced and by an expert.
Two mistakes recur. The first is a certificate signed by the advocate rather than by the person in charge of the device. The second is a certificate that describes a document nobody can match to the file on record, because the hash was never taken.
Where the complainant is an individual using a personal phone, the certificate is signed by that individual, describing the phone and the manner of the capture. Where the complainant is a company and the post was read on an office system, the certificate comes from the person in charge of that system, and a board resolution authorises the complaint. The mechanics are set out in the guide to getting a certificate under s. 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, and the standard the courts apply is discussed in the note on admissibility of digital evidence.
What only the platform or the police can produce
Three documents cannot be created by the complainant, however careful the file. They are the subscriber details attached to that account, the IP logs that place a particular device at a particular post, and the record of when the content was uploaded and edited.
No platform will hand these to a private person, and a request to the grievance officer for them will be refused, correctly. The route is an order for production of documents under s. 94 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023, sought by the investigating officer or by the complainant through the court. Ask for the account's registered mobile number, the email address, the registration IP and the last login IP, with the date range narrowed to the period around the post.
Build the request into the complaint from the beginning. A prayer for subscriber details added after the hearing is a second application, a second date, and often a platform that says the record has aged out of its retention window.
Proving that people read it, and proving the harm
Publication is proved by the people who saw the post, not by the post. Collect, in this order: screenshots of comments from named accounts, forwarded messages with the sender's number visible, emails or WhatsApp messages in which a client, employer or relative refers to the post, and a short signed statement from any person willing to say on oath that they read it and thought less of you.
Harm is a separate head of proof, and it is where most files are thinnest. Letters or emails withdrawing an engagement, a written inquiry from an employer, a notice from a professional body, a bank or a client asking about the allegation, and a medical record where the abuse caused diagnosable distress, all convert an insult into a loss that a court can measure.
Where the complainant is a business, add the certificate of registration, the GST registration, and a resolution authorising the person who signs the complaint. A trading reputation belongs to the entity, and the entity must be the complainant or be joined.
The bundle that goes before the Magistrate
A private complaint is filed with an index, a list of documents, the complaint itself, the affidavit, the documents in the order in which the list names them, the vakalatnama or the complainant's own signature where he appears in person, and the court fee. The court fee is set by the state court-fees legislation and by the rules of the court, and the current rate should be confirmed at the filing counter rather than assumed.
- Index and list of documents, paginated, matching the bundle.
- The complaint, signed on every page.
- The affidavit, sworn and notarised, with the date of knowledge stated.
- The captures with the certificate, kept as separate exhibits and not stapled into the body.
- The notice, the postal receipt and the reply, or the returned cover with the endorsement.
- The platform ticket and reply.
- The police complaint receipt or portal acknowledgement.
Number every exhibit and refer to the number in the paragraph that relies on it. A Magistrate reading a complaint that says the post is annexed, without saying which annexure, spends the first hearing asking for what should already be on the file.
When a document is missing
Document gaps are normal in this work, and each gap has a recognised substitute. What fails is a gap left unexplained.
- The post has been deleted. File the capture you made, the page address, and the date and time you last saw it live. Add a request that the platform confirm the deletion date and produce the pre-deletion record. A complaint describing a post that no longer exists is still maintainable.
- The original device is gone. The certificate then comes from the person who made the capture, describing the device as it then was, and the police can be asked to examine the account from their side.
- The account is anonymous. Describe the account and seek subscriber details under s. 94. The complaint names an unknown person and identifies him by the handle.
- No proof of harm. Lead with the words and their reach. Harm can be inferred from a serious imputation published to a defined audience, and the absence of a lost contract is not fatal to the offence.
- The publisher never replied to the notice. The postal receipt, the tracking record and the returned cover prove service, and silence then speaks for itself.
If money also moved to a receiving account
Some defamation complaints arrive attached to a fraud, where the publisher demanded payment to take the post down. That adds a set of financial papers that the cyber cell and the bank will want: the paying account statement, the transaction reference or UPI reference, the beneficiary account number and the name on it, and the complaint number under which the payment was reported.
Those papers travel with a separate request to hold the beneficiary account, and the list the bank works from is on the page about documents required to unfreeze a bank account. Keep the financial bundle separate from the defamation bundle, because they go to different desks and are read against different checklists.
What to do next
Assemble the file in the order set out above before the first consultation, and bring the device that made the captures. The chambers settle cyber defamation complaints and their annexures for filing in Kolkata and the districts, and the page on cyber defamation matters describes the work. Send the page address, the date of publication and the list of what you already hold through the chambers contact page, so that the gaps are known before the complaint is drafted.
Need help with a cyber crime matter?
Tell me what happened and I will tell you what to file, where, and by when. First conversation is free.
Call +91-9007000603 WhatsAppFrequently asked questions
Is a screenshot enough to file a cyber defamation complaint?
A screenshot starts the file but does not finish it. It must show the page address, the account that posted, and the date, and it needs a certificate under s. 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023 signed by the person in charge of the device. Without that certificate the capture is open to objection.
Who signs the electronic record certificate?
The person in charge of the computer or device on which the record was produced, together with an expert, in the form set out in the Schedule to the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023. Where an individual read the post on a personal phone, that individual signs and describes the device and the manner of capture.
Can I get the identity of an anonymous account holder?
Not directly. Platforms do not disclose subscriber details to private persons. The details are obtained through an order for production under s. 94 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023, either by the investigating officer or on an application to the court, and the request should be built into the complaint from the start.
What if the defamatory post has already been deleted?
File the capture you made, the page address, and the date you last saw it live, and ask the court or the police to require the platform to confirm the deletion and produce the record. A complaint about a post that no longer exists can still be maintained if the file shows what was published and to whom.
Information for general guidance only and not legal advice. Provisions cited follow the Information Technology Act 2000, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.
Related articles
Cyber crime lawyer in your city · Bank account freeze help · Contact