Call WhatsApp Consultation
Home › Legal Articles › Constitutional Law

NCRP Portal Complaint: When To Approach Court

By Advocate Panchanand Shaw, Bar Council of West Bengal · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Constitutional Law

A portal complaint that is registered and then left to sit is a common experience, and the law provides two routes out of it: a complaint to the magistrate and a petition in the High Court. Which one fits depends on whether the failure is to register a case or to act on one registered.

When the portal stops being enough

A complaint that is registered on the portal and then sits untouched is a common experience, and the law does not leave the complainant without a remedy. Two routes open from that point: an application to the magistrate where the police have not acted on the information, and a petition in the High Court under Article 226 where an authority has failed to do what the law requires of it.

Which route fits depends on what has actually failed. Where no case has been registered and the police simply will not move, the magistrate route is built for that situation. Where a case exists but the authority will not act on the file, the High Court is the forum that can direct a decision to be taken.

A third possibility is that nothing is wrong at all and the file is simply slow. Cyber cells carry heavy loads, and a complaint three weeks old may be waiting rather than refused. The remedy for a slow file is a written status request, which costs nothing and often produces an answer, and it is worth making before any court is mentioned.

The route to the magistrate

The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 replaced the Code of Criminal Procedure, and it carries forward the mechanism by which a person who has given information about a cognizable offence can approach the magistrate when the police do not act on it. The application sets out what was reported, what the police did, and asks the magistrate to direct that the matter be enquired into or investigated.

It is a written application, supported by the acknowledgement and the correspondence, and the magistrate may call for a report from the police before deciding. That report is often the first thing that makes a dormant file visible, because it compels the police to state on paper what has been done with the complaint and why nothing appears to have moved.

Timing matters here. The application should follow a reasonable period of silence rather than a few days of it, and it should be supported by the written requests already made. An application filed the day after the portal complaint was lodged is usually met with the answer that the police have not yet been given time to act.

The route to the High Court

A petition under Article 226 asks the High Court to direct an authority that has failed to act. In substance it is the writ of mandamus, and it lies where the duty is clear: to register a case, to investigate one, to decide a representation, or to release a hold that has no lawful basis. The court does not investigate the offence; it directs the authority to perform the duty it owes.

Where the target is a police-directed hold on a bank account, the petition challenges the continuation of that hold. The powers under which property may be attached and documents produced sit in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023, in ss. 106 and 107 on attachment and s. 94 on the production of documents. Those provisions authorise the process; they do not give an account holder a right to have the hold lifted on demand.

There is a further practical point. A writ petition is argued on the record, and where the authority says that a live investigation would be prejudiced by interference, the court may accept that answer for a time. The petition should therefore ask for what the record supports, and not for what the holder hopes to hear.

Comparing the two routes

RouteWhen it fitsWhat it can produceLimit
Application to the magistrateThe police have not acted on the information givenA direction to enquire into or investigate the complaintIt does not decide the fraud or return money
Petition under Article 226An authority has failed to do a duty, or a hold continues without basisA direction to act, to decide, or to release a holdThe court reviews authority, it does not try the offence
Banking Ombudsman complaintThe grievance is how the bank handled the accountRedress against the bank for its own conductNo jurisdiction over the police or the fraud

Read across the table rather than down it. The choice is made by identifying what is wrong, and the wrong thing is usually one of three: no case, no action on a case, or a bank that will not answer.

What a court can and cannot order

A court dealing with a cyber complaint can direct that a case be registered, that an investigation proceed, that a representation be decided within a stated period, or that a hold without lawful basis be lifted. Each of those is a direction about how an authority exercises its power.

What a court does not do in these proceedings is try the fraud, convict the person who took the money, or restore the sum to the complainant by its own order. Money returns when a receiving account is traced and the held balance is released, or when the case ends in a conviction and an order of compensation follows. A petition that asks a writ court to do any of that is asking for relief the forum does not give.

It is worth remembering that an order directing a decision does not command a favourable one. The authority may decide against the complainant and give reasons, and if it does, the remedy is to challenge those reasons rather than to ask again for the same direction.

The split among High Courts

Where the challenge is to a police-directed hold on a bank account, the High Courts have not spoken with one voice. The Kerala and Delhi High Courts have taken one view on whether such a petition is maintainable, and the Karnataka High Court has taken another. That disagreement is a split and not settled law, and an identical petition may be received in one state and questioned in another.

The practical consequence is that the framing carries as much weight as the facts. Before filing, the advocate must be able to say which line of authority the petition follows and why the record brings the case within it. A petition built on the assumption that the question is settled is the one most likely to meet a preliminary objection.

Where the petition is for non-registration or inaction rather than against a hold, the question is less contested, because the duty to act on information about a cognizable offence is a duty the courts have long been willing to enforce. The position when the police refuse to register is a useful starting point for that kind of matter.

What the record must show

Whatever the route, the same four things decide whether the court will interfere, and each is a fact rather than an argument.

Two of these usually carry the case. The record of a written request that went unanswered shows that the ordinary remedy was tried before the court was asked to step in. The identification of the transactions shows the court that it is dealing with a real and traceable loss rather than a general grievance.

A complainant who has filed on the portal, kept the acknowledgement, written twice to the cyber cell and once to the bank, and kept every reply is in a position to move either route. One who has filed and waited is not, and no amount of argument supplies what the file lacks. Where no case has been registered at all, registering a case for online fraud through the ordinary police route is often the step that comes before any of this.

One further point concerns urgency. Where a salary has stopped or a business cannot pay, the petition can ask for early listing and interim protection, and the High Court has the power to grant it. Urgency, however, must be shown from the dates in the file rather than asserted; a bare plea of hardship delays the very hearing it sought to bring forward.

A court reading a file in which the complainant wrote twice and heard nothing is in a very different position from one reading a file in which nothing was written at all.

What to do next

Before any court is approached, put the correspondence in order and let an advocate say which failure is being addressed, the failure to register or the failure to act, since the two go to different forums. The chambers of Advocate Panchanand Shaw, advocate practising before the Calcutta High Court and the district courts of West Bengal, advises on the right route and on how the petition should be framed. Send the acknowledgement, the statement and the correspondence through the contact page, and the first step will be an assessment of the forum, not a filing.

Need help with a cyber crime matter?

Tell me what happened and I will tell you what to file, where, and by when. First conversation is free.

Call +91-9007000603

Frequently asked questions

Can the High Court order the police to register my cyber complaint?

Yes. A petition under Article 226 can ask the High Court to direct that a case be registered, because registering a reported cognizable offence is a duty owed to the complainant. The court does not investigate the offence; it directs the authority to do what the law requires. Your acknowledgement and written requests form the basis.

What is the difference between going to the magistrate and going to the High Court?

The magistrate route is for the situation where the police did not act on the information you gave, and it asks for a direction to enquire or investigate. Article 226 is for a failure of duty generally, whether a refusal to register, a refusal to decide, or a hold continued without basis.

Will a court order the fraudster to return my money?

Not in these proceedings. A writ court directs an authority to act or to stop acting without power; it does not try the fraud or order recovery from the person who took the money. Money returns when a traced balance is released or when a conviction brings an order of compensation.

How long should I wait before approaching a court?

Long enough to show that the ordinary remedy was tried and failed: at least one written request to the cyber cell, one to the bank where an account is involved, and a reasonable period for a reply. An application filed within days of the complaint is usually answered by saying the police have not been given time.

Information for general guidance only and not legal advice. Provisions cited follow the Information Technology Act 2000, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.

Related articles

Cyber crime lawyer in your city · Bank account freeze help · Contact