Matrimonial Fraud: Documents You Must Produce
By Advocate Panchanand Shaw, Bar Council of West Bengal · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Cyber Law
A matrimonial fraud file is read by three offices, and each reads it for a different reason. The bank wants to know whether you authorised the debit. The cyber cell wants to know where the money went. The court wants to know whether the record can be exhibited. One bundle has to answer all three.
What the paperwork has to prove
No single document proves a matrimonial fraud. The file has to prove three separate things to three separate readers: that you are the person who paid, that the payment was induced by a false representation, and that the representation came from the account or profile you have named. Each of the three has a different custodian, and each produces a different kind of paper.
That is why a bundle that looks complete to the victim is often short at the counter. A bank statement proves the payment. It does not prove the profile. A screenshot of the profile proves what you saw. It does not prove the profile was the fraudster's.
The bank reads the file for authorisation: did you, or someone using your credentials, approve this debit. The cyber cell reads it for traceability: which account received the money, and what identifies the person operating the profile. The court reads it for admissibility: is this record what it claims to be, and can it be exhibited without an original.
Each reader will accept less than a full set, but each will reject a set that answers the wrong question. A statement without the beneficiary account details answers nothing. A screenshot without the device or the date answers nothing.
The identity set
Every forum needs to know who is complaining. Proof of identity, proof of the address used in the transaction, and, where the account was opened in someone else's name, the document that shows your authority to act. If the complainant is a parent or a sibling acting for the person defrauded, add a written authority; a complaint signed by a person with no visible connection to the transaction is returned, not registered.
- Identity and address proof that matches the bank record, not a document with a different spelling of the name.
- PAN, where the transaction was reported in the income tax return or where a large sum is involved.
- A signed authorisation where someone other than the account holder is filing.
- The acknowledgement number from the portal, once you have one, on the top sheet of every copy.
Proof of the payment
This is the part most complainants get right and most of them get wrong in detail. The bank statement must show the debit, the date, the amount and the reference number generated by the payment system. A UPI transfer shows a twelve-digit reference; a NEFT transfer shows a UTR; an IMPS transfer shows an RRN. Those strings are how the receiving bank finds the credit.
Order a statement for the relevant period with the bank's seal, and keep the plain download as well. The sealed statement is what a court accepts; the download is what a bank's fraud desk can read quickly on the day. If the payment was made by card, add the card statement and the merchant descriptor as it appears on it, because the descriptor is often the only clue to who received the money.
Where the money went to a wallet or a merchant, the payment aggregator's transaction record substitutes for a bank statement. Where the money was paid in cash, the receipt, the delivery of the cash in the presence of a witness, and the witness's own account become the proof, and a cash payment with no receipt is the weakest position in this area of practice.
Proof of the deception
The deception is proved by the trail the fraudster left before the money moved. Keep the profile as it appeared, with the name, photograph, description and the platform's own identifier for the account, and keep the messages that carry the false representation. A message that says what the person claimed to be, and a message that asks for money, are the two that matter.
Screenshots are accepted, but the versions that survive scrutiny show the date, the time, the device, and the path by which the screen was reached. A cropped image of a chat window with no header is the easiest document for the other side to attack. Keep the full screen, keep the sequence, and keep the originals in the application.
Where the fraudster sent an identity document to inspire confidence, keep it. A forged Aadhaar, a forged salary slip or a forged visa is not merely evidence of lying; it is evidence of forgery, and it changes the sections the police can apply.
What the bank issues, and what each paper establishes
| Document | Who issues it | What it proves |
|---|---|---|
| Statement with bank seal | Your branch | The debit, its date, amount and reference |
| Transaction dispute form | Your branch or the bank's fraud desk | That you disputed the debit, and when |
| Beneficiary account details | The receiving bank, usually on a police or court demand | Who held the account that took the money |
| Account opening record | The receiving bank, on a production order | Whether the account was a mule account |
| Chargeback or reversal reference | Card network or payment aggregator | That a recovery attempt was made and its outcome |
A certified copy of an entry in a banker's book can be obtained under the Bankers' Books Evidence Act 1891, and that route matters when the branch is slow. Ask for the certificate in the form the Act requires rather than a printout with a rubber stamp.
What the platform will give you, and what needs an order
The grievance officer will give you a response to your complaint and, on request, confirmation of the action taken on the reported profile. That response is useful because it is dated and comes from the intermediary rather than from you. What the officer will not give is the subscriber's registration details, the mobile number attached to the account, the IP log of the logins, or the payment details of any premium subscription.
Those come on a production order under section 94 of the BNSS, addressed to the platform's nodal contact. In practice the investigating officer drafts it, the platform's law enforcement response team answers it, and the answer is what converts your screenshot into a named accused. A preservation request sent early, even before the order, is worth making: platforms will hold data for a limited period on request, and data that has been deleted cannot be ordered back. The filing that produces that order is set out in the procedure for a matrimonial fraud complaint.
Substitutes when a document is missing
Missing documents are normal, and most have a lawful substitute. What is not curable is an invented one; a fabricated receipt ends the complaint and creates a worse problem than the original loss.
| Missing | Substitute | What it still proves |
|---|---|---|
| Original statement | Certified copy under the Bankers' Books Evidence Act, or a fresh statement on request | The debit and its reference |
| Deleted chat | Platform data export, linked-device backup, or the recipient's copy | The representation and the demand |
| Screenshot without date | Screen recording made now, with the device clock visible and a certificate | The content, though weaker on timing |
| No receipt for cash | Affidavit of the payer plus the evidence of the person present | The payment, by testimony rather than by document |
| Profile deleted | Grievance officer's response naming the profile, plus any archived copy | That the profile existed and was reported |
The certificate that makes an electronic record admissible
An electronic record is proved under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023, and the certificate under section 63(4) of the Adhiniyam is the one that decides whether your screenshots are read at all. The Adhiniyam requires a certificate identifying the record, describing the device and the manner of extraction, and dealing with the hash value where the record is produced from a computer resource. Without it, the record is objected to and the objection usually succeeds.
The certificate is signed by the person in charge of the device or the management of the relevant activity, and it is not a formality to be filled at the end of the case. It should be prepared while the device still holds the record, and it should accompany the record when it is filed. The certification practice of the Calcutta High Court is the useful model for the form, and a document set assembled without it is the commonest reason a technically sound complaint fails at the evidence stage.
Where a forensic lab extracts the record, the lab's report and the certificate travel together. Where you extract it yourself, the certificate is yours to sign, and it must describe what you actually did rather than what a template says.
Common defects that send a bundle back
- Name spelling that differs between the bank record, the identity proof and the complaint.
- Amounts that do not reconcile between the statement, the portal form and the covering note.
- Screenshots that show the message but not the sender's identifier.
- A statement for the wrong period, missing the very transaction complained of.
- No certificate under the Adhiniyam, so the electronic record is objected to and excluded.
- Documents in another language without a translation, which the court will direct you to file later.
What to do next
Build the bundle in three folders, one for each thing it has to prove, and put the portal acknowledgement on top of each. Get the statement sealed, get the screenshots certified, and keep the originals on the device that produced them. If a document is missing, decide on the substitute before you file rather than after the counter returns the file. The chambers of Advocate Panchanand Shaw settle document sets for cyber-fraud complaints in West Bengal and appear on the resulting matters in the Calcutta High Court and the district courts. Begin with the contact page and send the acknowledgement number with the draft bundle.
Need help with a cyber crime matter?
Tell me what happened and I will tell you what to file, where, and by when. First conversation is free.
Call +91-9007000603 WhatsAppFrequently asked questions
Do I need the original bank statement or will a download do?
Both, for different readers. A download is what the bank fraud desk reads on the day, and a statement bearing the branch seal or a certified copy under the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act 1891 is what a court will exhibit. Ask the branch for the sealed statement covering the transaction, and keep the download untouched on your own device.
What if the fraudster deleted the profile before I could screenshot it?
The grievance officer’s response becomes the substitute. It is dated, it comes from the intermediary, and it usually identifies the profile complained of. Add any archived copy, a linked-device backup, or a message the profile sent to another user. A production order under section 94 of the BNSS can then obtain the subscriber details.
Is a screenshot enough to prove the conversation in court?
Only with the certificate the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023 requires. The certificate identifies the record, the device and the manner of extraction, and is signed by the person in charge of the device. A screenshot without it is objected to, and the objection usually succeeds. Keep the original on the device that produced it.
Which documents show that the receiving account is a mule account?
The account opening record and the statement of the receiving account, obtained by the investigating officer on a production order. They show when the account was opened, how it was operated, and whether the credits were withdrawn immediately. A victim cannot obtain those documents independently, which is why the FIR matters more than a private bundle.
Do I need an affidavit with the document set?
Usually a short one. It sets out the chronology, identifies each document and states how it came into your possession, which is what the court reads first. Where a document is missing and you rely on a substitute, the affidavit carries the explanation. It must match the documents exactly, since discrepancies are what the other side attacks.
Information for general guidance only and not legal advice. Provisions cited follow the Information Technology Act 2000, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.
Related articles
Cyber crime lawyer in your city · Bank account freeze help · Contact