Call WhatsApp Consultation
Home › Legal Articles › Cyber Law

Data Breach Compensation: Documents Required

By Advocate Panchanand Shaw, Bar Council of West Bengal · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Cyber Law

A data breach file is read by four different people, and each of them wants a different sheet of paper. This article sets out the full checklist: who issues each document, what it proves, and what you can use when a document was never issued to you in the first place.

What the file has to prove

Every document in a data breach compensation file answers one of four questions: were you inside the dataset that leaked, did the incident happen as you describe, what did it cost you, and who is entitled to claim. A paper that answers none of those four is weight, not evidence. Build the file around the questions and the list stops looking endless.

The readers change; the questions do not. The organisation's grievance officer, the Data Protection Board of India, a civil court, a consumer commission and the cyber cell all want the same four answers, and each asks for them in a different order and under a different label.

The checklist, and who issues each paper

This is the whole list. Everything else a counter asks for is usually one of these under another name.

DocumentWho issues itWhat it provesIf you do not have it
Breach notice from the organisationThe data fiduciaryThat it accepts an incident touching your dataIts published notice, or a regulator's public statement naming it
Account, policy or customer recordThe organisationThat it held your data and under which identifierOnboarding email, statement, or any letter quoting your customer number
Identity proofUIDAI, Income-tax Department, passport officeThat you are the person whose data was heldAny officially accepted alternative identity document
Bank or card statement showing the lossYour bankThe date, amount and beneficiary of each debitThe bank's written confirmation of the transaction
Dispute or chargeback acknowledgementYour bankThat you reported the loss, and whenThe reference from the bank's own grievance log
Invoices for money spent because of the breachThe service providerThe out-of-pocket lossReceipt, order confirmation, or the matching bank entry
Employer's letter on leave takenYour employerLoss of pay or leave caused by the incidentSalary slip showing the deduction
Complaint acknowledgement from NCRPThe national cyber-fraud portalThe date and reference of your criminal complaintThe SMS or email carrying the reference
Copy of the FIRPolice station or cyber cellThat a case exists, and what it allegesThe station's receipt, or a certified copy later
Certificate under s. 63(4), Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023The person in charge of the device that produced the recordThat the electronic record is authenticNothing else substitutes; see below
Legal heir certificate or succession certificateRevenue authority or courtThat you may claim for a person who has diedAffidavit of relationship, pending the certificate
Authority letter or power of attorneyYou, or the person you act forThat you may act for someone elseAn affidavit where the person cannot sign

Papers that put you inside the dataset

The hardest element in a data breach claim is not the loss. It is proving that your data was in the set that leaked. The best paper is the organisation's own notice addressed to you, naming the data involved. Next is any document showing it held that specific data: the account opening form, the policy schedule, the onboarding email, the KYC record. Then comes the identifier, such as the customer number, policy number or employee code, because that is what ties every other paper to the same person.

Where the organisation will not confirm, ask the question in writing and keep the answer. A refusal to confirm, on the record, explains why you went to the Board and why you could not annex the admission earlier. Silence on a written question is itself a fact worth putting in the file.

Papers that prove the incident

Three sources carry different weight. The fiduciary's own notice is evidence. A regulator's or agency's public statement naming the entity is strong corroboration. A news report naming the entity and the date shows only that you had reason to inquire, and it will not carry a claim alone.

Ask the organisation for its internal incident reference and for the date it reported the incident to the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team. Entities are required to report cyber incidents to CERT-In under directions issued under the Information Technology Act 2000, so a reference should exist. Whether they hand it to you is a different question, and the written request belongs in the file either way.

Keep the original notice as it arrived: the email with full headers, the letter with its envelope, the SMS with the sender identifier. A forwarded copy loses the header, and the header is what shows who sent it and when.

Papers that prove the loss

A court computes loss; it does not estimate it. So the file needs three layers: the debit, the cause, and the consequential spend.

  1. The debit. Statements for the whole period, not the single page carrying the disputed entry, so that the pattern around it is visible.
  2. The cause. Something that connects the debit to the data that leaked: a password reset you never asked for, a loan application quoting your PAN, a call referencing an order you placed.
  3. The consequential spend. The re-KYC charge, the new card, the credit report, the travel to a branch, the leave taken to attend to it.

Do not annex a notarised statement of loss you cannot support with one of these. It reads as an admission that the rest of the file is thin, and it invites the reader to test every other number in the bundle.

Where the loss is a loan or a credit line opened in your name, add the sanction letter and the bureau report showing the enquiry. Those two papers do more work than a paragraph of explanation, because they come from the lender rather than from you.

The certificate for every electronic record

Screenshots, emails, portal receipts and call logs are electronic records. Under s. 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023, an electronic record is proved by the certificate in the form that section sets out, signed by the person in charge of the computer or device on which the record was produced. Section 63 replaced the certificate route that had sat in s. 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, which the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam replaced.

The practical effect: a screenshot printed and annexed without the certificate can be objected to, and the objection is often upheld. Keep the device that made the record, note the hash where you can, and sign the certificate yourself where the record came from your own phone. Where the record came from a portal, the portal's own downloadable acknowledgement is stronger than a screenshot of the same page. The steps for the certificate are set out in the s. 63(4) certificate guide.

Papers for a claim brought for someone else

Where the data principal is a parent, a spouse or a person who has died, the file gains one layer before anything else is read: the authority to act.

Courts read the authority paper before they read the merits. A strong claim filed by someone with no visible right to bring it is adjourned, not heard.

What the cyber cell and the Board each add

The police file and the compensation file overlap but are not the same. The cyber cell works from the transaction: the date, the amount, the reference, the account that received the money. Its own checklist is set out in the NCRP complaint documents list, and it is worth reading before you visit the station so that you carry one bundle rather than three.

The Board's complaint adds two papers of its own: your written notice to the fiduciary, and proof that it reached them. That receipt is the whole foundation of the complaint. Without it the Board is being asked to inquire into a conversation that may never have taken place. Where the organisation has a published grievance policy, annex the page that states the response period, because it fixes what counts as a failure to reply.

Substitutes that work, and substitutes that fail

A missing document is normal. A missing document replaced by invention is fatal, so the substitution has to be honest and has to come from someone other than you wherever possible.

There is also a substitute that costs nothing and is often overlooked: a written request to the organisation asking it to confirm a fact, kept with the reply. If it confirms the fact, you have your document. If it refuses, you have the refusal, and the refusal is a document too. The evidence that has to be captured quickly, before it decays, is covered in the first-48-hours evidence guide.

What to do next

Build the file in the order the table sets out, and keep one paper copy and one scanned set. Mark each sheet with what it proves, in a single line, because a reader who has to work it out will assume it proves nothing. Where a paper is missing, insert the written request you made for it rather than a gap. The chambers of Advocate Panchanand Shaw, practising before the Calcutta High Court and the district courts in West Bengal, settle data breach files and the connected cyber-fraud complaints. To have the bundle reviewed before it goes to a counter, use the contact page.

Need help with a cyber crime matter?

Tell me what happened and I will tell you what to file, where, and by when. First conversation is free.

Call +91-9007000603

Frequently asked questions

Is the organisation's breach notice enough on its own?

It proves the incident but not that your data was in it. Pair the notice with a document showing the organisation held the specific data, such as the policy schedule, account record or onboarding email, and with the identifier it uses for you. The notice plus the identifier is what puts you inside the affected set.

What do I do if the bank will not give me a written confirmation?

Escalate through the bank's own grievance channel and keep the reference of each request. If the refusal continues, a complaint to the RBI Ombudsman under the Integrated Ombudsman Scheme produces a written record. In the meantime, the statement itself, with the debit highlighted, is the primary proof.

Do screenshots need a certificate to be read in court?

Yes, where they are relied on as electronic records. Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023 requires a certificate in the prescribed form from the person in charge of the device that produced the record. A screenshot without it can be objected to, and the objection is frequently upheld.

Can an affidavit replace a document I was never given?

It can explain the gap, but it cannot create a record. An affidavit is strongest where it states a fact that another paper corroborates, such as a payment the bank statement also shows. Where the affidavit is the only proof of the central fact, expect the reader to discount it.

Information for general guidance only and not legal advice. Provisions cited follow the Information Technology Act 2000, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023 and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.

Related articles

Cyber crime lawyer in your city · Bank account freeze help · Contact